How the Inventory Working Group Tests Its Findings
Why we publish working reports before they are final
CoRWM's Inventory Working Group does not wait until every answer is settled before it shares its thinking. We publish working reports while our findings are still provisional, because the inventory is a shared national picture and the people who use it deserve to see how it is being built. A working report is a snapshot, not a verdict.

This approach matters because radioactive waste inventory data comes from many sources: site operators, regulators, and legacy programmes. Those sources change, and so do the questions we ask of them. Publishing early lets us test our assumptions against real scrutiny instead of polishing them in private.
How public comments shape the results
Every working report is opened for comment. We read each response and log it against the specific finding it addresses. Comments are not a popularity contest; they are evidence. A single detailed correction about a waste stream can change a table, a total, or a recommendation.
The process follows a clear rhythm:
- Publish the working report with a comment period.
- Log and categorise every submission.
- Ask the original data provider to confirm or correct the point.
- Revise the finding and explain the change in the final report.
What we look for in feedback
Not all comments carry the same weight. We prioritise those that identify a specific number, source, or method. General statements of support or opposition are noted, but they rarely move a finding on their own.
- Clear references to published data or site records.
- Corrections to units, dates, or waste categories.
- Questions that expose a gap in our method.
We also track themes across comments. If many respondents raise the same uncertainty, that is a signal that our final report must address it directly.
From comment to change: a worked example
In a recent working report, a respondent questioned how we grouped certain intermediate-level wastes. The comment pointed to a category boundary that did not match current regulatory guidance. We checked the source, agreed, and revised the grouping in the final version.
The table below shows how a single comment can travel through the process.
| Stage | Action | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Comment received | Logged against finding 4.2 | Accepted for review |
| Verification | Checked against guidance | Boundary corrected |
| Final report | Change explained in annex | Finding updated |
Why this matters for trust
Our final findings are stronger because they have been tested in public. As one reviewer put it, "The working report gave us something concrete to argue with, and the final report showed that the argument mattered."
Publishing early is not a sign of uncertainty; it is a commitment to being correctable.
The Inventory Working Group will continue to publish working reports before they are final. If you want to shape the next one, watch corwm.org for open comment periods and send your evidence-based comments when they appear.
